AccreditedInvestorsClub.com lionAccreditedInvestorsClub.com
Text/WhatsApp: (808) 600-9260

Guide

Restricted Securities and Rule 144 in Plain English

Restricted securities are shares you received in a private deal, such as a private placement or an equity grant, rather than in a public offering. You can't resell them freely. Rule 144 is a common path to resell them. It usually depends on how long you have held them, whether the company shares current public information, and whether you are an insider.

What makes a security restricted

Most investors think of stock as something you can sell any day. Restricted securities work differently. They are shares sold without SEC registration, usually in a private placement. Restricted stock refers to securities, usually issued in private placements, that have limited transferability. You may also hear them called legended stock or lettered stock. The names come from the legend printed on the certificate or noted on the account, which says the shares can't be resold without registration or an exemption.

Securities sold under Rule 506 are restricted securities. That includes many private equity funds, venture deals and single-deal vehicles. If you invest through one of those, you are holding something that can't be sold the way a public stock can. Our guide to Private Equity for Accredited Investors shows how that plays out in practice.

What Rule 144 does

Rule 144 gives holders of restricted securities a way to resell them in the public market without registering the sale. It sets conditions. If you meet them, you can sell. If you don't, you usually have to wait or find another exemption.

Rule 144 is not the same as Rule 144A. In his book, Richard C. Wilson lists Rule 144A as an SEC exemption permitting the sale of certain restricted stock without registration. In practice, 144A deals are mainly among large institutional buyers. Most individual holders will look at Rule 144.

The main conditions

The details vary by situation, but these pieces come up most often:

  • Holding period. In many cases the minimum is six months if the company reports to the SEC and is current in its filings. It is usually one year if the company doesn't report.
  • Current public information. For a reporting company, the company generally needs to be up to date in its public filings. This matters most for insiders and for sales within the first year.
  • Volume limits. Insiders face a cap on how much they can sell in a three-month period. It is generally tied to a share of the outstanding stock or to recent trading volume.
  • Manner of sale. Insiders generally sell through ordinary brokerage transactions and file a notice with the SEC when they sell above certain size thresholds.

The holding period starts when you paid for the shares in full, not when you first heard about the deal. Our short answer, How long must I hold restricted stock before selling?, goes through the timing questions.

Insiders versus everyone else

Rule 144 treats two groups differently. An affiliate is someone with a control relationship with the company, such as a director, an executive officer or a large shareholder. A non-affiliate is anyone else.

A non-affiliate holding shares of a reporting company can often sell freely once the holding period is over. After a year, the current-information condition usually falls away as well.

An affiliate keeps the volume limits, the manner-of-sale rules and the notice filing, even after the holding period ends. Affiliates also hold shares that are not restricted, called control securities, and those follow similar rules. Being an insider changes your selling rules for as long as you stay one.

Restricted stock, RSUs and options at work

The word "restricted" shows up in two ways, and people mix them up. One meaning is the securities law restriction on resale. The other is a vesting restriction in a pay plan.

Here is how Richard C. Wilson's book describes common equity pay:

  • Restricted stock. These are grants of actual stock. The shares can't be sold until they vest through continued employment or performance goals. Grants typically include dividend and voting rights.
  • Restricted stock units. These are a promise to deliver stock later. No stock is granted until the vesting conditions are met. At that point the value of the delivered shares is subject to personal income tax.
  • Stock options. These let you pay a purchase price to acquire company stock after vesting. Incentive options can get capital gains treatment if holding periods are met. Non-qualified options are taxed when you exercise and acquire the shares.

The book also notes that private companies granting options need to set the exercise price at fair market value on the grant date. This is usually done with an independent valuation each year.

Vesting and Rule 144 are separate questions. Your shares can be fully vested and still be restricted securities. Tax holding periods are also separate from securities law holding periods.

If this sounds like you

Executives with equity pay. You may have restricted stock, RSUs or options from several grants, each with its own vesting date. If you are a director or executive officer, you are likely an affiliate. That means volume limits and notice filings. Company trading windows and blackout periods can apply too. Keep a simple list of each grant, its vest date and its type.

New money after a business sale. If you took stock in the buyer as part of the deal, those shares are often restricted. Check the legend and the holding period start date. You may also be tied to lockups in the sale agreement, which are separate from Rule 144.

Windfall or inheritance. Inherited or gifted shares may still carry restrictions. In many cases the original holder's holding time carries over to you. Find out how the shares were acquired and when they were fully paid for.

Seasoned investors. If you hold fund interests, you may find they have no public market at all. Rule 144 doesn't create a buyer. A private fund interest usually has transfer terms in its own documents. SPVs and Single-Deal Vehicles Explained covers how those terms work.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming vested means sellable.
  • Counting the holding period from the wrong date.
  • Forgetting that affiliate status can last after you leave a role.
  • Selling in a blackout window.
  • Overlooking lockups in a sale or financing agreement.
  • Putting too much of your wealth in one stock you can't easily sell.

On that last point, Richard C. Wilson's book also reminds readers to check that any investment fits with, and diversifies, their current holdings. It is just as relevant when the investment is shares you were handed.

Five panelists sit with microphones in front of windows, with audience members in the foreground.
Photo from a Family Office Club event.

Frequently asked questions

Does Rule 144 apply to my private fund investment?

Rule 144 is about reselling securities in the public market. Most private fund interests have no public market, so the fund's own documents usually control transfers. Your interest is still a restricted security, and any transfer generally needs an exemption.

Are RSUs restricted securities?

RSUs are a promise of shares, so there is nothing to resell until they vest and are delivered. Shares you receive on vesting from a public company are often already registered, so Rule 144 may not apply. Shares from a private company are usually restricted.

Does the holding period restart if I move or give the shares away?

Moving shares between your own accounts generally doesn't restart it. In many cases a gift or inheritance lets the new holder count the earlier holding time. Each situation depends on how the transfer happens, so keep your records of when the shares were first paid for.

This site is built from over 19 years of Family Office Club workshops, bootcamps, masterminds and investor events. The club has 17 million registered LinkedIn group members, 19 million social media followers in total, 345 events held and $1B in transactions completed between our members.

Sources
Richard C. Wilson

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club over 19 years ago.

If you want to talk through your situation, the private deals you are seeing, or how Family Office Club events and membership could help, email richard@familyoffices.com or text or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 (WhatsApp). You can also see Family Office Club events and membership.

AccreditedInvestorsClub.com is an educational site from the Family Office Club. It is not affiliated with the SEC or any regulator, does not offer or sell securities, and nothing here is investment, legal or tax advice.