AccreditedInvestorsClub.com lionAccreditedInvestorsClub.com
Text/WhatsApp: (808) 600-9260

Checklist

Operating Agreement Review Checklist

This checklist covers the governance rules, economic rights, transfer limits, and reporting standards found in an LLC operating agreement or shareholder agreement. It helps first-time accredited investors, seasoned investors, and business owners evaluate direct private deals and fund syndications. Reviewing these terms carefully ensures that your rights match your expectations before signing.

Governance and Major Decision Rights

In his book on family office investing, Richard C. Wilson writes that direct investors should establish clear voting thresholds for major business events rather than relying on informal understandings.

  • Voting thresholds for major actions. Check which decisions require a supermajority or unanimous vote rather than a simple majority. Look closely at rules for selling company assets, taking on major debt, or changing the core business.
  • Issuance of new equity. Verify whether the manager can issue new units or admit new members without investor approval. Unrestricted issuance rights can dilute your ownership and voting power.
  • Manager removal and replacement. Review the exact process for removing a manager for cause, such as fraud or gross negligence. Make sure the agreement defines what qualifies as cause and states what percentage of units is required to vote on a replacement.
  • Changes to governing documents. Check the voting requirements needed to amend the operating agreement itself. A manager should not have the unilateral right to change your economic or voting rights.
  • Officer authority and signatory limits. Look for dollar limits on contracts, borrowing, or asset pledges that the manager can enter without member approval. Setting boundaries helps prevent unauthorized commitments.

Economics, Fees, and Capital Calls

Economics define how and when you get paid, what fees are taken, and whether you must provide extra money later. You can also review Operating Agreement Key Terms for Passive Investors for deeper explanations of waterfall structures.

  • Cash distribution waterfall. Trace the exact order of cash distributions. Confirm whether passive investors receive a preferred return before the manager takes a promote or carried interest.
  • Management and sponsor fees. Identify every fee payable to the sponsor or its affiliates, including acquisition, asset management, and disposition fees. Check whether these fees are deducted before calculating your preferred return.
  • Mandatory capital calls. Determine if the manager can demand additional capital from investors. If mandatory calls are allowed, verify the penalties for non-participation, such as dilution or loss of voting rights.
  • Tax allocations and distribution timing. Confirm that the agreement provides for mandatory tax distributions. Without these, you might owe income taxes on allocated profits without receiving the cash to pay them.

Transfer Rights, Exits, and Liquidity

Private securities issued under exemptions like Rule 506 are restricted securities, meaning resale is limited. The operating agreement often adds further contractual restrictions on how and when you can exit.

  • Right of first refusal. Check if the company or other members have the right to match any outside offer if you want to sell your units.
  • Drag-along and tag-along rights. Review drag-along terms that force you to sell your units during an approved company sale. Ensure there are tag-along rights so you can participate on the same terms if the founders sell their stake.
  • Permitted transfers. Confirm that you can transfer units to family trusts, estate planning vehicles, or wholly owned entities without triggering costly manager approval processes.
  • Buyback and redemption terms. Note whether the company has the option to force a buyback of your shares. If a redemption right exists, check how the valuation is calculated.

Information Rights and Reporting

Investors need access to regular financial information to monitor their holdings and prepare annual tax filings.

  • Financial statement delivery. Look for explicit deadlines for receiving quarterly and annual financial statements. Annual statements should state whether they will be audited or unaudited.
  • Schedule K-1 delivery deadlines. Ensure the agreement commits to delivering tax packages by a specific date, such as March 15 or June 30, so you can plan your tax filings.
  • Inspection rights. Check your right to inspect company books, records, and member registers. Some agreements restrict access to basic contact lists, making it harder for minority owners to communicate.
  • Consistency with offering materials. Cross-reference the operating agreement against the summary in the private placement memorandum. You can use our PPM Review Checklist to make sure all fees and terms match across both documents.

Common mistakes

  • Relying on verbal promises. Assuming side discussions with the sponsor will apply even if they are missing from the written agreement.
  • Overlooking mandatory capital calls. Missing penalty clauses that can heavily dilute your ownership if you do not fund an unexpected cash call.
  • Ignoring affiliate transactions. Allowing the manager to hire affiliate companies at above-market rates without member consent.
  • Skipping dispute resolution terms. Failing to check whether the agreement forces arbitration in a distant state, which can make resolving disagreements expensive.
Five seated panelists hold microphones against a blue-lit curtain backdrop.
Photo from a Family Office Club event.

Frequently asked questions

How does an operating agreement differ from a private placement memorandum?

A private placement memorandum is an informative disclosure document that explains the investment opportunity, company background, and risk factors. The operating agreement is the binding contract that actually governs the legal rights, cash flows, and management duties of the company. If there is a direct conflict between the two documents, the operating agreement usually controls.

Can an operating agreement waive the manager's fiduciary duties?

In many states, LLC laws allow operating agreements to limit or eliminate traditional fiduciary duties, provided the manager acts in good faith. You should check the indemnification and exculpation sections to see how much liability protection the manager receives.

What should I check regarding manager conflicts of interest?

Look for clauses that require transactions between the company and the manager or their affiliates to be on competitive, arms-length terms. In his book, Richard C. Wilson points out that major conflict-of-interest transactions should require the approval of disinterested investors to ensure company assets are protected.

This site is built from over 19 years of Family Office Club workshops, bootcamps, masterminds and investor events. The club has 17 million registered LinkedIn group members, 19 million social media followers in total, 345 events held and $1B in transactions completed between our members.

Sources
Richard C. Wilson

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club over 19 years ago.

If you want to talk through your situation, the private deals you are seeing, or how Family Office Club events and membership could help, email richard@familyoffices.com or text or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 (WhatsApp). You can also see Family Office Club events and membership.

AccreditedInvestorsClub.com is an educational site from the Family Office Club. It is not affiliated with the SEC or any regulator, does not offer or sell securities, and nothing here is investment, legal or tax advice.